I don’t know if this is a startling
notion to you, but I do believe history repeats itself. We’re going through
another of our tumultuous times, with respect to the Middle East. When is this
not so? The Arab Spring may have sprung. Sprung into what, depends on which set
of babbleheads you listen to and are able to ‘cipher. Like Jethro, my ‘cipherin’
has gotten a hell of a workout. Also, my bullshit meter broke yesterday.
But I did come away with some truths
and a whole new batch of ugly; crystallized and clarified. It hit me initially
as I was reading the always-wonderful “Eat the Press,” live-blogged by the
marvelous Jason Linkins on HuffPost. I really look forward to his Herculean efforts
each week. I always find something gut-bustingly funny, a lá the “Air Force and
the freaking Hittites,” a laff riot, fer shure, and new perspectives. He’s a
breath of fresh air, but Jason is pointedly objective and doesn’t pander, nor
is he impressed by pedigree or “experience.”
Nope, he’s just trying to make sense
out of the whole furball that is Washington D.C. and now, the geo-political
egg-beater that is the fertile, or non-fertile crescent. I highly recommend
anyone reading this post who has not read yesterday’s "Eat the Press" post to do so; it’s
a winner. Shameless plug for Mr. A. Linkins over, let’s move this here post along.
History, the Middle East and
Civilizations; ooh, what fun! What got me going down “memory lane,” which by
the way is strewn with IEDs, is this quote, on a picture of recently-slain
Christopher Stevens “In 1979 Muslim terrorists took American hostages and our
President appeased them. Since then they have murdered Americans:” then, there
is a list of incidents where Americans were in fact, murdered in the Middle
East. The tagline at the bottom reads “Yes, the problem is clearly a film on
YouTube,” as you can see.
This picture is one that is
currently posted on a FB page created by: I Pledge Allegiance To My Country Not MyPresident (54,035 likes - 181.729 talking about this) Apparently, a page that hates Everything Obama. The lies just start
right off the bat. Jimmy Carter was President and he did not appease the terrorists to get the hostages released. He tried
negotiating right up until he left office, for 444 days, to get them released
from the American Embassy in Tehran. President Carter even attempted a rescue
mission that failed and left 8 U.S. servicemen and 1 Iranian dead. This
culminated in the Algiers Accords in Algeria, signed on January 19, 1981. The
hostages were released the next day on January 20, 1981, minutes after Ronald
Reagan took office.
There was NEVER any appeasement. The
U.S. does not appease terrorists. Asynchronous warfare doesn’t work via
appeasement. The idea is to dampen it, not feed the beast. If you pay attention
to it, it will grow, spread. If you spew hate, it will spew back. All of those
incidents in the picture happened, but it is completely disingenuous to say “AMERICANS”
were killed WITHOUT saying “JEWS,” “MUSLIMS,” “SOMALIANS,” “KENYANS,” “AFGHANS,”
“LIBYANS,” were killed. If you are going to sloganeer, try adding in a few more
nationalities that were also present during the catastrophes. It tends to lend
verisimilitude to your slant.
People who make these kinds of sites
have no idea the scope and depth of what they’re really tampering with. This
part of the world is old beyond old. It’s nearer the cradle of civilization and
has seen conflict from the beginning. Afghanistan has been fought over for so
long, it barely knows another way to live. The only other place on earth that
is probably as inhospitable as regards invaders is western Russian. Well, shit,
they were only invaded like 5 or 6 times in the first half of the 20th
century. People say they’re paranoid. They’re just alert.
Afghanistan is the graveyard of
empires. Rightly so. The British Empire came to grief there as did Russia, in a
spectacular way in the early 80s with our help. But, just think on this. Go and
think of ancient Rome. When a Roman General came home after he conquered new
territory, he was granted a Triumph. He would ride in his chariot up the
Triumph Port. His slave, or a slave granted for use during the Triumph would stand
behind him whispering “Respice te, hominem te
memento" ("Look behind you, remember you are only a
man") and "Memento mori" ("Remember
(that you are) mortal").
So too, should countries remember
this. We are man- or woman-stuff. We can be killed, collectively-speaking, or
at least changed to something that is no longer recognizable. We can’t just pop
on down via the Apian Way to the Coliseum to watch the Chariot Races, anymore.
We have similar Bread and Circuses, and that is the point. It’s all familiar
isn’t it. It was to Bin Laden.
It is a reflection of what we have
sown; dragon’s teeth, complete with flames. Think of the fires in Benghazi,
last week; kinda dragon-ish. Well. Back to our friend, Mr. Jason Linkins; here Mr.
Linkins in “HuffPo’s Eat the Press, yesterday,
refers back to an interview in 2001:
Let me just print this whole section from a 2001 interview with Robert Fisk (hat tip:Gawker):
Q: At
the beginning of the war, you said the U.S. might be falling into a trap. What
did you mean?
Fisk: If it is bin Laden, he's a very
intelligent guy. He's been planning his war for a long time. I remember the
last time I met him in 1997 in Afghanistan. It was so cold. When I awoke in the
morning in the tent, I had frost in my hair. We were in a twenty-five-foot-wide
and twenty-five-foot-high air raid shelter built into the solid rock of the
mountain by bin Laden during the war against the Russians. And bin Laden said
to me (he was being very careful, watching me writing it down), "From this
mountain, Mr. Robert, upon which you are sitting, we beat the Russian army and
helped break the Soviet Union. And I pray to God that he allows us to turn
America into a shadow of itself." When I saw the pictures of New York
without the World Trade Center, New York looked like a shadow of itself.
Bin Laden is not well read and he's not
sophisticated, but he will have worked out very coldly what America would do in
response to this. I'm sure he wanted America to attack Afghanistan. Once you do
what your enemy wants, you are walking into a trap, whether you think it's the
right thing to do or not.
Q: And what is that trap?
Fisk: To bring the Americans in, to strike so
brutally and with so much blood at an innocent Muslim people that an explosion
comes throughout the Middle East. Bin Laden was constantly revolving in his
mind the fact that he had got rid of the Russians; therefore, the Americans can
be got rid of, too. And where better than in the country where he knows how to
fight?
As things continue, it will be more and more
difficult for the dictators, kings, and princes in the Middle East to go on
justifying this. They are going to have to start saying, "No, stop."
When they do that, the United States is going to have to ignore them. Once they
are ignored, they lose the last element of respect. The longer this war goes
on, the better for bin Laden.
We put bin Laden on the bottom of the ocean.
Hume seems to want us to join him there. Because: RESPECT, BLARGLE.
Back to my prose. So, to sum up, let’s
NOT talk about this. Let’s NOT choose sides and fight about this on FB. Let’s
NOT rant at one another about Muslims and anti-Muslims. Terry Jones did a
reprehensible thing in promoting his whole Burn the Koran day on 9/11 when he started it in 2010. Terry Jones is always and will forever be an asshole for
his stupidity. This is one of many acts of infamy and indecency he has
committed. Whether or not he promoted a really stupid, amateurish film and people raised hell over it, is something else. If anyone should have started firing rockets, it should have been people who make good films. But by hitting back, by answering the inflammatory rhetoric, new little dragon teeth get planted.
Florida is full of assholes. So. What. Yesterday, the assholes were at the news studios of NBC, ABC and FOX News. I don’t have to add to this
discourse. I don’t have to add to the dialogue that gets any more Americans or
Middle Easterners killed, as much as I love the region and the people. They’ll
do better without my attention. America would do better than to pay them
attention as well. Back in the early 20th century, there was a surge
in isolationism. After WWI, the Senate did not ratify Woodrow Wilson’s Treaty
of Versaille and the U.S. did not become a member or the League of Nations. We’ve
always had this duality in our nature, partly because we’re still at heart a
nation of immigrants, who, big surprise, have put down roots. It’s hard to
argue for or against. This time, we need to stay home, or come home; we don’t
understand the mindset. I will continue to watch and listen and learn and bother Jason Linkins on Twitter, but I'll be damned if I'll blog about it again. A very special thanks to a very, very special lady.
2 comments:
always there are the dragon's teeth - believe it or not Afghanastan was a beautiful coountry once - this old lady can remember it -traveled safely and happily throughout it - as part of the brit empire I despaired when we went in (again) - why don't leaders read the history books? - why dont they travel a mile in other's shoes?
Thank you for visiting and the comment; it is so appreciated. Yes, I can believe that once Afghanistan was a beautiful place. Shortly after 9/11, there were several documentaries on the National Geographic channel that focused in and around Khyber Pass. Having read Kipling and studied the region, I was so fascinated by the people. I always have been a history buff. My parents were arm chair historians. Our leaders don't read the histories or if they do, care not about the long term. I fully believe they do what is expedient or what serves their agendas. They can talk puffery about noble causes all they want, but I see no principles applied, not really. Even our own President is not really seeking Freedom for oppressed people. I have a feeling that in this case, we have the justification of "the greater good," which I have a problem accepting. If I'm a moral absolutist, so be it. I could never bear the thought of anyone, or any country being ruined for what, really? Thank you so much for visiting. Next time, I'll make tea. Mary
Post a Comment